Skip to content
Que vérifier avant d'acheter sa première cave pour ses cigares Que vérifier avant d'acheter sa première cave pour ses cigares

What to check before buying your first cigar humidor

What to check before buying your first cigar humidor

Updated November 16, 2026

What to check before buying your first humidor? Six points are enough: the seal of the lid, the type of cedar lining, the quality of the included humidifier and hygrometer, the actual capacity, the strength of the hinges, and where it will live in your home. Before comparing cigar humidor models, keep this checklist handy: it helps avoid most first-time buyer disappointments.

In short

To know what to check before buying your first humidor, keep these six checks in mind: a lid that closes without any play, a genuine cedar lining, a clear and reliable hygrometer, a humidifier sized for the volume, a capacity calculated based on your cigar sizes, and a stable location away from sunlight and heating.

Les six points de contrôle 1Joint du couvercle 2Cèdre intérieur 3Hygromètre 4Humidificateur 5Capacité réelle 6Charnières et un septième : l’endroit où elle sera posée
The six points to check on a cedar humidor before choosing one, plus its future location.

How to check the seal of the lid?

The seal is the first criterion, because a leaking humidor loses its humidity in a few days, regardless of the rest of its equipment. The simplest test takes just a sheet of paper: slide it between the box and the lid, close it, then pull gently.

If the sheet resists all around, the seal is good. If it slides freely at a corner or on one side, air is circulating and the humidity will drop. Repeat the test on all four sides: a slightly warped lid often leaks in only one place.

A second clue can be noticed when closing it. On a well-fitted humidor, the lid descends at the end of its travel by pushing out the air, with a slight cushioning. A lid that snaps shut or remains slightly ajar by a few millimeters indicates an approximate fit.

Good to know

On a glass-fronted humidor, also check the perimeter of the glass: an uneven adhesive seal or glass that moves under your finger is a second source of leakage.

Solid cedar or plywood: how to tell the difference?

The cedar lining regulates humidity and protects the tobacco leaves; its quality therefore matters as much as that of the exterior. Look at the edge of the dividers and the rims: solid wood shows a continuous grain through the thickness, while plywood reveals a thin layer glued onto a particleboard panel.

The smell also helps: genuine cedar smells distinctly of wood when opened. To understand why this difference matters for maintaining humidity levels, our technical guide on solid wood versus plywood explains the subject in detail.

Are the included hygrometer and humidifier reliable?

The hygrometer included with a humidor is a useful indicator, but it must be checked before trusting it. The salt test allows you to do this overnight: a pinch of table salt barely moistened, placed with the hygrometer in an airtight bag, stabilizes the air around 75%.

If the device displays 70 or 80% after eight to twelve hours, note the discrepancy and mentally correct each reading. A hygrometer that can be read without opening the lid, on the front or behind glass, is a real convenience: every opening causes the internal humidity to fluctuate.

What humidifier for what volume?

Check that the humidifier is sized for the volume of the humidor: a small disc is enough for about twenty places, not for a drawer unit. It must be easy to remove and refill, with distilled water or a solution designed for this purpose, never tap water.

Tip

If the included humidifier seems undersized, plan for a second element or two-way regulating sachets from the start: they absorb excess and release missing humidity.

Is the stated capacity the actual capacity?

Rarely. The displayed capacity is calculated based on a reference size, often a medium-diameter robusto, packed as tightly as possible. With thicker or longer sizes, the actual number drops significantly.

You also need to leave air: a humidor that is three-quarters full regulates better than a packed humidor. In practice, aim for a stated capacity about a third higher than what you plan to store. To calculate precisely according to your cigar sizes, use our capacity calculation method.

Finally, measure the useful height and length inside, with dividers in place. A fixed divider can prevent long sizes, even if the total volume seems sufficient.

What to look for on the hinges and closure?

The hinges determine the long-term seal: a lid that develops play after a few months will no longer close properly. Prefer screwed-in metal hinges, with no side play when you gently shake the open lid.

  • Stability when open: the lid should stay open on its own, without falling back onto your fingers.
  • Alignment: when closed, the lid should sit flush with the box on all four sides, without visible misalignment.
  • Closure: magnet, latch, or lock, it must hold the lid flush without forcing it.
  • Screws: they must not penetrate the cedar lining or rust when exposed to humidity.

In the middle of these criteria, the choice becomes simpler: a cedar humidor for your cigars that ticks these four points will last for years without special adjustment.

Where to install your first humidor at home?

Decide on the location before buying, because it dictates the size. The humidor must be placed away from direct sunlight, far from a radiator, fireplace, or kitchen, in a room where the temperature remains around 18 to 21 °C.

Measure the available surface and the height under the shelf, open lid included. A drawer humidor placed on a sideboard requires depth; a flat humidor can slide onto a bookshelf. Finally, avoid closed closets where strong odors linger: cedar and tobacco absorb them.

The workshop's opinion

For a first humidor, we advise looking first at where the hygrometer is read, then at the height of the unit. The CARBON fiber carbon humidor illustrates a good starting size: 35 cigars, Spanish cedar lining, electronic hygrometer readable on the front without opening, and only 6.8 cm in height for 26 × 22 cm, which allows it to fit on a shelf.

If you already buy your cigars by the whole box, it is better to aim bigger from the start. The EAMES five-drawer humidor offers 110 places, a full Spanish cedar lining, two glass drawers, a drawer dedicated to the humidifier, and a hygrometer visible behind its glass door. Weighing around 5 kg, it requires a stable piece of furniture.

What to check before buying your first humidor: the complete checklist

This table covers the checks point by point, with the signal that should alert you.

Point How to check Warning signal
Lid Paper test on all four sides The paper slides freely in one place
Cedar lining Edge of the rims, smell, material mention Visible particleboard panel, no smell
Hygrometer Salt test overnight Discrepancy of more than 5 points, stuck needle
Humidifier Size relative to volume, easy refill Small disc in a large volume
Capacity Reference size, useful height Capacity calculated without dividers
Hinges Side play, open stability, alignment Lid that falls back or shifts
Location Open lid dimensions, distance from heating Direct sunlight, kitchen, scented closet

What mistakes to avoid on your first purchase?

The most common is buying too small: a collection grows quickly, and a saturated humidor regulates poorly. The second consists in judging a humidor on its exterior alone, without looking at the seal or the cedar.

Storing your cigars as soon as you receive them

A new cedar humidor arrives dry: left as is, it would draw the humidity from your cigars. It must be conditioned for 24 to 48 hours before placing anything in it; the complete method is in our guide for preparing a new humidor before the first storage.

Choosing based on price or the brand of the model

A prestigious name does not guarantee a fitted seal or solid cedar. Apply the same checklist to every model, whatever its range: it is the same points that make a good twenty-place humidor as a hundred-place one.

Warning

An acrylic humidor without cedar is suitable for a quick rotation of a few weeks, not for aging over several months: it does not regulate humidity on its own.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a glass-fronted humidor retain humidity as well as a solid humidor?
Yes, if the glass is well sealed and the frame is rigid. Glass does not exchange humidity, so it does not harm regulation; it brings a little less thermal inertia than thick wood. Simply place a glass-fronted humidor out of direct sunlight, which would heat the interior and cause the humidity to fluctuate in a few hours.
Digital or needle hygrometer: which one to prefer for starting out?
Digital is read more precisely and reacts faster to variations, which is reassuring at the beginning. The needle model, more traditional, requires more regular calibration and is read with a few points of margin. In both cases, the essential is to check it with salt before use and to be able to consult it without opening the lid.
Is a strong smell of wood upon delivery normal?
Yes, it is even a rather good sign: genuine cedar gives off a clear woody fragrance, especially when it is new. This smell fades after conditioning and the first weeks of use. On the other hand, a smell of glue, varnish, or solvent should alert you: leave the humidor open and aired before any storage.
Can you buy a used humidor without risk?
It is possible, provided you inspect the interior carefully. Look for white or bluish stains on the cedar, a sign of mold, and tiny round holes, a sign of past insects. Do the paper test on the lid, then clean dry and condition the humidor like a new one before storing your cigars in it.
Is a key or code lock useful?
It does not improve the seal: that is done by the seal and the fit of the lid. A lock is mainly used to protect a valuable collection in a shared office or a house with children. If you choose one, check that it does not force the lid crookedly when closing, which would create a leak.

With your checklist in hand, compare the models point by point: capacity, cedar, hygrometer, and size.

Discover our selection of humidors

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

Back to top